Think Twice about Cookie-Cutter Landscapes


Cookie-cutter landscapes don’t show any personality.

Who doesn’t need help from a professional from time to time? A plumber when the toilet keeps backing up? An electrician when the wall outlet makes sparks? A dentist when you have a toothache? When it comes to landscaping, too, there is nothing wrong with calling in a professional landscaper to guide you when you’re not sure where to start or you have a problem that you think is insurmountable.

There are of course many factors to consider in choosing a landscape contractor: cost, availability, experience, etc. But my personal belief is that the most important thing is to find someone who is willing to listen to you: who will adapt the landscape to your needs, your tastes and your budget.


This is my own front yard. I like to think it practically screams “laidback gardeners live here”.

Let’s be honest here. Not all landscape contractors put a lot of effort into creating personalized landscapes: some take approximately the same plan with about the same structures and pretty much the same plants, then scale it up or down so as to suit almost any terrain: what I call a cookie-cutter landscape. I’m not saying such a landscape can’t be attractive, but it can certainly be a bit monotonous, and worse yet, it rarely reflects the people who live in the home. Such a landscape could belong to anyone. Don’t you want a yard that says “I’m Joe Blow and this is what I’m like”? I sure do.

Look for Examples

Before hiring a landscape contractor, then, ask to see his portfolio. Does he show a wide range of styles or does every photo somehow seem similar? Ask for references and go see the results firsthand. Above all, try to see some landscapes he put in not just last month, but 4 or 5 years ago. Too often you see landscapes that are quite attractive at first, but don’t hold up over time. And question him about the plants he intends to include. It is shocking to see how little some so-called landscape experts know about plants other than sod and “cedars” (Thuja occidentalis). If you’re not a plantsman yourself, get an opinion about any plant suggestions from a friend who is.


If you want to put a vegetable garden in your front yard, why not?

And before you even see the potential contractor, hold a family council. What do you really want? If you want an English-style flower border, a perfume garden, and a front yard vegetable bed and the contractor presents you with a plan featuring a lawn, paving stones and a pergola, you’re talking to the wrong person.

Custom Design

As a laidback gardener, I want my landscape to require only a minimal amount of maintenance. Mowed lawns are what require the most care in any landscape; shrubs and trees, the least. So if the plan is 90% lawn, I certainly wouldn’t be interested!

And I don’t mind getting my hands dirty and that might be your case too. Ask the contractor if he can develop a multi-step plan you can achieve yourself over several years, of course with assistance for any complex work (better to leave certain structures, such as the main entrance and stairs, where security is vital, to an expert).

Good luck in your search: there are good landscape contractors very open to personalized landscapes out there. You just have to find one!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s