Gardening Houseplants Laidback Gardener Tip of the Day Plant propagation

A Valentine’s Day Horticultural Rip-Off

Hoya leaf cuttings sold as plants.

Gardeners are often the victims of horticultural rip-offs, attempts by greedy suppliers to grab their money in return for dud plants, useless products, or ineffective services. Why wouldn’t they try to make a quick buck from Valentine’s Day too?

The Love Leaf

Anything to make a sale!

You’ve probably seen one and if not, head straight to your local garden center, as they are probably selling them right now: a thick, leathery, green heart sitting all on its lonesome in a small pot. It’s the leaf of Hoya kerrii, sometimes called wax hearts, sweetheart plant, love leaf, or Valentine hoya, and its unique heart shape is certainly surprising. Sometimes the vendor even pushes the envelope so far as to write “I love you” or something similar on the leaf or paint flowers on it. How cute! It sounds like a nice little gift for Valentine’s Day. What’s the problem?

The problem is that, as a gardener, you expect this rooted leaf to grow into plant, right? That, when you bring it home and lovingly care for it, it will one day grow new stems, more leaves and – who knows? – maybe even flowers.

If so, you’ll be severely disappointed. Because the leaf will probably never produce a new stem or other leaves. In the rare case in which it does, that can take years. It usually can’t, because neither the leaf or its petiole has any dormant bud from which new stems can grow. This is called a blind cutting.

Your blind leaf can live for years without growing and without changing: a sort of horticultural living dead (not much of a Valentine’s Day symbol, is it?). After 7 years or so, if you continue to take care of it (and its needs are fairly minimal: a sprinkling of water every now and again will suffice and of course, no fertilizer is ever needed), it will simply die one day, having lived out its leafy life.

Very occasionally, a love leaf will, after some 7 to 10 years, put out a stem. That’s because a tiny bit of stem was torn off with the leaf and that did include a small dormant bud. But most hoya leaf cuttings are simply blind.

What Happened?

This rubber plant leaf is blind: it has produced numerous roots, but no stem. Photo:

Hoyas aren’t the only plants with with leaves that root and never produce a stem. There is a surprising number of plants whose leaves you can coax into rooting, but that will go no further. Several Ficus species, for example, such as the rubber plant (Ficus elastica) and the fiddle-leaf fig (F. lyrata), produce blind leaves. On Facebook forums, I often see thrilled indoor gardeners marveling over the leaf cuttings they took of a rubber plant: “Look,” they crow, “my leaf has roots!” They all look forward to the huge and beautiful rubber plant it will one day become, but they are going to be bitterly disappointed. No plant will ever grow from a rubber plant leaf cutting. A stem cutting, sure, but not a leaf cutting. It too will live on for years, then die for no apparent reason. Such is the way of blind leaves.

Take Your Own Hoya Cuttings

Stem cuttings of hoya will produce new stems and leaves. Photo:

If you have a hoya at home or a neighbor or friend willing to share a piece, you can easily take cuttings of it… but they will need to be stem cuttings. Insert the lower end of a section of stem with at least two leaves into moist potting soil and, after a few months (hoyas are often very slow to start), the cutting will begin producing new stems and new leaves from dormant buds located on the buried part of the stem, at the leaf axils. You can even take a leaf cutting, at least sort of, as long as you include, along with the leaf, a section of the stem at its base, as that is where the dormant bud will be found. This is called a leaf-bud cutting and it must include a stem section with an axillary bud. Both the stem and leaf will then take root, but only the stem has the ability to produce a new plant, because only it bears buds.

Of course, there are plants you actually can grow from leaf cuttings or even leaf sections: African violets, crassulas, sansevierias, etc. But they all have the ability to produce adventitious buds, that is, buds that appear outside of the usual places. Hoyas, like most plants, don’t have that capacity: they’ll only sprout from axillary buds, buds found on the stem, at leaf axils, not from the leaf or any part of the leaf.

Buying a Sweetheart Plant


Hoya kerrii ‘Albomarginata’

H. kerrii makes an excellent houseplant… as long as you buy a plant, not a leaf. I have had one for years, in fact, a particularly charming form with variegated leaves called H. kerrii ‘Albomarginata’. Its growth is somewhat uneven (as with many hoyas, it seems sit for months, then suddenly puts on a spurt of growth for no obvious reason) and mine has not yet bloomed… and that’s normal, because it often takes up to 7 years before it starts to flower and my plant is only 4 years old.

Maintenance is a snap because H. kerrii tolerates almost any combination of indoor conditions: sun or shade (although fairly intense lighting is required for bloom), slightly moist to almost dry soil, a humid atmosphere or a dry one, frequent or sporadic fertilizations, etc. What it won’t tolerate is cold: try to keep temperatures above 60?C (15?C) at all times. H. kerrii is a climber and can be allowed to work its way up some sort of support, like a trellis. However most people use it in a hanging basket, allowing its stems to extend downwards. Do feel free to shorten the very long stems that occur occasionally.

So, off you go: pick up your own sweetheart plant with its heart-shaped leaves on this day dedicated to romantic love… but do buy a plant, not a leaf!


14 comments on “A Valentine’s Day Horticultural Rip-Off

  1. Pingback: Heart-leaved Houseplants for Valentine’s Day – Laidback Gardener

  2. Maria A lobo

    Hearing about the leaves not producing plants, I finally bought a plant with 5 leaves and the new leaf is not showing any variegation and is curled backwards, hope it will straighten out an show some color.

    • It might not straighten out (but there should be healthy ones to come), but the color tends to come in late, as the leaf hardens off, so you’ll probably get that.

  3. Vel Rhodes

    Bought a single leaf,( variegated), seven years ago. This year it started to grow a stem out of the bottom area. The mature leaf quickly dried up. The vine now has nine large unvariegated leaves and a long stretch of vine with no leaves. I have cut off the vine a couple of inches past the last leaf. I’m going to cut this long part into segments and pot them up in pro mix. Think this will work?

    • It might. It’s an extremely slow-growing plant, so leaving it alone would probably have worked as well. Certainly you can expect some sort of leaf growth from what’s left of the vine… eventually!

  4. well I bought mine from Bunnings for Mum and it was $11. shocked to see today that the rocks around it are all glued down…. bit horrified to hear it might not turn into a plant. would have liked a warning on the label…..would not have paid that much for it….lol…..Mum is now convinced it is plastic because it is doing nothing! lol

  5. Ken Albin

    I don’t know why you have so much trouble growing them from a single leaf. I purchased mine as one leaf. If didn’t do much for about 6 months and then a long vine sprang up from it. The only trouble I have with the plant now is that it wants to take over the entire window and spread into the house so I have to occasionally prune the long vines back some. The first time I did this I potted 4 leaves and gave them away as gifts. All of the leaves sprouted vines within a few months with no trouble.

  6. Jaime Paryse

    I had been gifted years ago the one leaf in the little pot…it stayed like that for years but then it started growing or of the blue and Vining up to the ceiling out of the same tiny pot. I finally repotted into a slightly larger pot and it continues to grow. It’s flowering now. I must have had it for 10 years now but it did eventually grow. Wish i could post a pic!

  7. Marie-Michelle

    Thank you so much. You just saved me £10 🙂

  8. Thanks for letting me know, my heart leaf is from Bunnings and was reduced to $4, I was wondering how to look after it and how to get it out of its little pink pot, it seems to be fixed in it permanently in concrete!

  9. I love it! Rip-off–the only propagation technique I do.

Leave a Reply

Sign up for the Laidback Gardener blog and receive articles in your inbox every morning!