Nematodes Versus Ants Review: So-so Results

Standard

Photo: Premier Tech Home & Garden

I recently tried using beneficial nematodes to control ants in my yard. Not that I really had to: I’m pretty open to ants as long as 1) they stay outdoors and 2) don’t attack people. But I had recently taped a TV show about using nematodes to control insect pests and ended up bringing home a sample of AntOut Nematodes. Since I had the product, I figured I’d try it and write about the results.

The product in question comes in a round plastic ball and does not require refrigeration. (This is fairly new; previous generations of nematode treatments required refrigeration both in the store and at home.) It does have a limited life span, though, and has been to used the year in which it was purchased. 

Background Story

Steinernema feltiae as seen under a microscope. Photo: http://www.amazon.co.uk

Nematodes are microscopic worms. There are thousands of species, some of which are harmful to plants, but many others are parasites of insects. That’s the case of Steinernema feltiae, the species of nematode used in the Green Earth product. Besides ants, this species can treat other pests such as flea beetles, houseflies, sawflies and fungus gnats. Other nematode species and strains are available that control white grubs, chinch bugs, fleas and other pests.

Two Test Colonies

Meadow ants build tiny mounds and aren’t really worth treating. Photo: University of Nebraska Extension

I have dozens of colonies of meadow ants (Lasius spp.), little brown ants that make small crater-shaped mounds of soil particles with an entrance hole in the center. They’re found in my lawn, gardens and among paving stones. They’re essentially beneficial: they aerate the soil, pick up detritus and do no harm to my plants. I’ve never bothered trying to eliminate them, nor do I intend to: live and let live, I say. I’m assuming most other gardeners feel the same way.

Field ant nests are larger, have multiple entrances and tend to kill the surrounding vegetation. Photo: uwm.edu

However, there were two colonies of field ants (Formica spp.) in my yard. These are larger ants, usually black (mine were), although they do come in other colors, and they build bigger sandy-looking nests with multiple entrances. They’re not carpenter ants (they live in wood) and almost never go indoors, but their large nests often destroy plantings and sections of lawn, mostly through burying plants and excessive tunneling. They’ll even bite if you attack their nests, but their bite is more surprising than painful. And field ant colonies are long-lived: up to 10 years. 

Given their more harmful nature, I decided field ants would be the ones I would treat.

Field ant (Formica spp.). Photo: Mathias Krumbholz, Wikipedia Commons

One colony was in my lawn and had been there for a number of years. Not being a lawn person, I had simply been ignoring it. My belief was that this colony was in decline: it didn’t seem that vigorous. I’ll call it the lawn colony.

The other was a new one, first seen this spring, and it was coming up near my front door, half in paving stones and half in a flower bed. Their mound was growing weekly. I’ll call them the paving stone colony.

The Treatment

I first read the label on the product and it suggested spraying them onto nests. However, on the Web site I found instructions for watering them in … much more practical for me.

The tiny filter bag containers filler, but also invisible-to-the-eye nematodes. Photo: laidbackgardener.blog

It certainly was simple enough. I was to soak the area the previous day (done), then open the ball and remove the tiny filter bag of filler that container the dormant nematodes. As instructed, I dropped the bag into a 5-gallon watering can and filled it with water. 

The nematode solution has to be watering in or sprayed on.

Apparently, the product can cover 16 ant nests or up to 3000 sq. ft (275 m2), but I had only two nests. So, I slowly poured about one quarter of the solution onto and around the lawn colony, then did the same for the patio one. After, I repeated simply because I had enough product to do so. Then I was to water the product in, which I did.

Follow-up was to consist of watering daily for four days. I did that too.

The Results

There is nothing left of the lawn colony and grass and other lawn plants are filling back in. Photo: laidbackgardener.blog

By day 4, the lawn colony was gone. Not a living ant has appeared since and the lawn is actually filling in already. But the patio colony showed no reaction at all and continues to prosper.

My thoughts: the lawn colony might have been especially susceptible to the nematodes, since it seemed already to be on the decline, while the patio colony, being young, might have been more vigorous and resistant. Or perhaps the main nest was out of reach of the nematodes, situated as it was under patio pavers. 

At any rate, the nematodes are supposed to multiply and remain alive for the season, so they might yet seek out and destroy the patio ant colony. And I would think conditions are good for them right now, as it has been rainy ever since I applied the nematodes. However, they’re not tolerant of prolonged periods below freezing and will likely be killed in the cold winters where I live. So, if the colony does not reappear next spring, that could still be the results of this summer’s treatment. If so, I’ll update this article. 

However, at this point, treating ants with nematodes doesn’t seem to be a miracle solution, working in some cases, but not in others.

At least you’re now forewarned!

One thought on “Nematodes Versus Ants Review: So-so Results

  1. Ants can be a problem by spreading scale, as well as other related insects. In my garden, problematic plants can be pruned away from touching other plants or garden features, and access to their trunks can be blocked with a bit of grease. Since ants can not fly, they are unable to get into such inaccessible targets. However, such pruning would detrimentally change the appearance of plants in gardens that are more lush. That is where controlling ants would be an asset.

Leave a Reply to tonytomeo Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.