Gardening Plant propagation

Fall is For Dividing Too!

By Larry Hodgson

For many gardeners, there is only one season to divide their garden plants: spring. However, fall is actually just as suitable and sometimes even better for this age-old method of plant propagation.

What Plants Can You Divide?

Talk to any gardener about division and they’ll almost immediately think of perennials. And it’s true that you can divide almost any perennial. But then, you can also divide bulbs, grasses and even some shrubs. 

Whether a plant can be divided or not is pretty easy to figure out. If there is only one stem or growth rising from the soil, clearly it can’t be divided. There’s nothing to divide: division implies there is more than one plant. I’m not saying such a plant can never be divided: perhaps in a year or so it will produce an offset or two, but until it does, no dice!

On the other hand, if the plant grows in a clump with several to many crowns or tufts of leaves either crowded together or more widely spaced apart, there is clearly more than one plant growing there. It might have been all on its own when you first planted it, but now the “plant” is really a cluster of plants and you can divide it.

Why Fall?

Fall is a great time to divide most plants. After all, temperatures tend to be cooler and the soil is often moister, both of which help promotes rooting. Plus, most gardeners have more time on their hands than in the spring. Spring is often a mad rush to get things done. In the fall, you can do one thing at a time, and at your leisure.

A cushion aster with purple flowers.
The one group of plants you shouldn’t divide in the fall are those that bloom in the fall, like this aster (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae ‘Grape Crush’). It’s best to divide fall bloomers in the spring. Photo: www.perennialresource,com

The big exception is that, ideally, you wouldn’t divide in the fall plants that are in bloom in the fall. When plants are in flower, they use up more energy and are more likely to suffer stress than when they’re just vegetating. Plus, you would need to remove the flowers from any plant you divide, but why shorten their blooming season? So, if you can, put off dividing fall-blooming plants, such as asters, black-eyed susans, echinaceas and fall-flowering sedums, until spring. For all the others, such as those that bloom in spring or summer or those, like ferns, don’t bloom at all, fall division is perfectly fine.

Why Divide?

Root ball of a perennial after digging it up.
Most often, when dividing a perennial, it’s in order to have more specimens of the same plant. Photo:

There are several reasons for wanting to divide a plant. 

  • The most obvious reason is to have more plants! Indeed, you’ll find it’s possible to divide certain plants, such as a mature hosta or daylily, into 40 plants or more, giving you enough to create a beautiful and inexpensive border.
Division to control an invasive perennial.
For perennials that can be a bit invasive, dividing usually consists mainly of digging out the excess plants to limit their spread. Ill.: Claire Tourigny
  • Also, some perennials are just too domineering: if left to grow on their own, they soon start to invade their neighbors. In this case, you don’t necessarily want more plants, you divide them so as to have fewer plants! Dividing therefore becomes primarily a method of control.
  • For yet other perennials, the proliferation of offsets at the base of the mother plant means it gradually becomes overcrowded. Then the plant becomes less vigorous and flowering decreases. By dividing to leave only a few clumps rather than dozens, the plant’s vigor returns and its flowering will too.
  • Finally, there are some perennials, such as coreopsis and gaillardias, which, if left on their own, don’t live very long. Gardeners often call short-lived perennials and they only last three or four years, maybe five. However, dividing such plants rejuvenates them, setting the timer back to year one. If you divide them every three years or so, they can live for decades.

Doing the Deed

When you divide a plant in the spring, there is no foliage—or only just a few buds starting to sprout—to get in your way. You can see exactly what you’re doing. In the fall, though, most perennials are still in full leaf when you divide them and, if the foliage is at all tall or thick, you won’t know where to start.

So, for once, cut back the leaves. Yes, usually you never cut back the healthy leaves of any plant, but this is an exception. Don’t be too concerned that cutting the leaves while they are still green will harm the plant, because by fall, the growing season for most perennials is close to being over. The leaves are still there, but they are no longer really contributing much to the plant. 

So, cut back the foliage close to the ground: that could be 6 to 8 inches (15 to 20 cm) above the soil for large perennials or 2 to 3 inches (3 to 8 cm) for smaller ones.

Complete Division

The whole root ball of a perennial is being dug up.
Sometimes you want to get the whole plant out of the ground for division purposes. Photo: The Impatient Gardener

This is the classic division, the one shown in most gardening books. It’s used either for plants that are difficult to divide or for perennials that you want to dig up and move anyway.

Division of a peony.
With herbaceous peonies, it’s better to rinse the roots of soil to better see where to cut. Ill.: Claire Tourigny

Take the peony as an example. 

The herbaceous peony falls under the category of plants that “don’t like to be disturbed.” To divide it with as little stress as possible, though, fall division is ideal. It’s already essentially dormant and has been so since August, so division at this season will be less of a shock to its system.

With this sturdy-looking but actually delicate plant, it’s best to dig up the whole root ball. To do this, dig as deep as you can—the roots of the peony are long—all around the plant and hoist the plant out of the hole, setting it on the ground nearby. Rinse the roots well with a garden hose. You will see that the “mother plant” is actually made up of several plants linked together by carrot-shaped roots that are often intertwined. Now that the soil is removed and you can see what you are doing, cut between the plants, leaving each plant at least three to five buds (divisions with only one or two buds are possible, but will be years away from flowering).

For each division, dig a planting hole 3 times as wide as the root ball and as deep as needed to house it. You can mix compost or a little slow-release fertilizer with the soil removed to enrich it.

Replanting a division to the same depth as the original plant.
Replant the divisions to the same depth as they were originally. If they are bare root, it can be helpful to place a mound of soil in the bottom of the hole and place the plant on it, spreading its roots in all directions. Ill.: Claire Tourigny

Replant the divisions to the same depth as they were originally, usually with the crown barely exposed, centering them in their hole. Herbaceous peonies are a bit of an exception. Plant them with the buds underground, pointing up, but never more than 2 inches (5 cm) deep. Planting too deeply may interfere with flowering

Note that a divided peony can take 3 to 5 years before flowering profusely, but it’s an exception. Most other perennials are faster and will flower vigorously the year following division!

Partial Division

Any good laidback gardener knows that you don’t have to dig up the entire root ball to divide most perennials.

Dividing a perennial by digging out a section.
You can cut out a section out of a clumping perennial without digging it up. Photo: Gary Bachman, MSU Extension.

If you just need a few more plants, or if your goal is to control an overgrown perennial, why disturb the mother plant by going through all the hassle of lifting the whole thing out of the ground? Just take a sharp spade and dig up a section from its outer rim. It’s like slicing a piece of pie: take a sharp shovel or spade, push it into the plant once, twice, then a third time and cut out a chunk of plant with attached roots.

It’s best to harvest the section behind the mother plant so that the removal doesn’t affect the plant’s appearance too much the following year.

Fill the hole left behind with good soil and then water well. The mother plant won’t react in the slightest to this minor intrusion!

Depending on the plant, it may be helpful to use a garden hose to rinse the soil off the chunk of plant you just removed. That will give you a better view of what you have to do. You will no doubt find that the “pie slice” harvested contains several plants, sometimes even dozens, each with its own tuft of leaves and roots. Pull the plants to separate them into individual plants (if you want as many plants as possible) or into clumps of three or four plants (for a faster recovery). If you can’t pull them apart, use a knife to slice between the plants. Then, simply replant them in a suitable location at their original depth.

Finishing Up

Aftercare for fall-planted divisions simply involves watering when you finish, then again as needed over the coming weeks so the soil doesn’t dry out. You can also cover them with 2 to 4 inches (5 to 10 cm) of good mulch. (Don’t worry: they’ll grow right up through the mulch come spring.) Don’t hesitate to use as mulch the very leaves you cut off your perennials before you divided them: there is nothing a perennial likes better as mulch than its own foliage!

Almost all of your fall-divided perennials will be in bloom again the very next year! 

Garden writer and blogger, author of 65 gardening books, lecturer and communicator, the Laidback Gardener, Larry Hodgson, passed away in October 2022. Known for his great generosity, his thoroughness and his sense of humor, he reached several generations of amateur and professional gardeners over his 40-year career. Thanks to his son, Mathieu Hodgson, and a team of contributors, will continue its mission of demystifying gardening and making it more accessible to all.

4 comments on “Fall is For Dividing Too!

  1. This is great, and should be obvious, but sadly, we must dig and divide some of our perennials now, since they are in the way of other projects. Other infrastructure projects are not scheduled according to seasons like our horticultural projects are. For example, I needed to pull up some cannas to facilitate the repair of a concrete retaining wall that contains their area. I know it would have been beter for them to die back, but I did not have the option of waiting. I dug them, and heeled them in. Now they are growing as if it is spring! Oh my! I really made a mess of their schedule. Well, I know they will adapt, even after their new growth dies back for winter.

  2. Marjorie Mould

    Good article. Thank you. You mention even some shrubs can be divided. Would a Spirea fall into the category of those that can be divided? Also, what about Heather?

Leave a Reply

Sign up for the Laidback Gardener blog and receive articles in your inbox every morning!

%d bloggers like this: