Gardening Heritage vegetables Hybridizing Vegetables

The Story of the Lemon Cucumber

Do you know the lemon cucumber? It’s an actual cucumber cultivar—Cucumis sativa “Lemon”—with round fruits about the size of small orange and even a protrusion at the tip much like the navel of a navel orange.

The fruits start off light green, but turn yellower as they mature. They’ll be lemon yellow by the time of harvest, that is, assuming you want to harvest them early, for their fleshy fruit. They have a very mild flavor and, unlike, other cucumbers, no bitterness. And, again, unlike others, they’re quite sweet, with a Brix of 5.4%. At this stage, many people feel lemon cucumbers have a lemony taste or flavor, whence the name. And quite a few prefer their extra-mild flavor to the more typical, somewhat bitter, burp-causing garden cucumber. (See Belch No More with Burpless Cucumbers?)

If you want to harvest your lemon cucumbers for their seeds (for next year’s sowing, for example), you need to let them mature further, letting them become orange or even brown. But at that point, they will no longer be edible.

Where Does the Lemon Cucumber Come From?

Two photos: yelloe cucumber flower, white orange blossom.
Is the lemon cucumber really a hybrid between a cucumber flower (left) and an orange flower (right)? Photos: Dleonis & photomaru, depositphotos

The story goes that a self-taught hybridizer created the lemon cucumber in the early 20th century by plucking an orange blossom from his daughter’s bridal bouquet and using its pollen to fecundate a garden cucumber flower. The result was a rare intergeneric hybrid, a cross between an orange and a cucumber, with the size, shape and color of a citrus, but the crispness and seediness of a cucumber.

So, what do you think?

Well, that’s nonsense, of course. ‘Lemon’ is just a cucumber. It carries no citrus genes. You can’t cross a cucumber, in the squash family (Curcubitaceae) with a plant in the citrus family (Rutaceae). It would be the equivalent of crossing a dog with an ostrich!

Old As the Hills

In reality, the lemon cucumber is probably just a very ancient cucumber. A true heritage vegetable, as it’s very similar to the wild cucumbers of India. This is where botanists believe all cucumbers originated. Some of these had a rounded shape and yellow or red skin, although also bore a considerable number of long spines as well. (The lemon cucumber skin is nearly smooth, bearing only a few tiny, inconsequential black spines.) This incongruous lot were the ancestors of today’s garden cucumbers.

Various Indian cucumbers.
Indian cucumbers come in a wide array of sizes, colors and forms. Photo:

Suspicions are that not only did the lemon cucumber’s ancestors originate in India, but that it was also developed as a crop there. Today Indian farmers grow a wide range of shapes, colors, textures and flavors of cucumbers and the lemon cucumber wouldn’t even stand out from the crowd.

Its lack of bitterness and ease of digestion are due to it being low in cucurbitacin. If you don’t usually like cucumbers, bite into a ‘Lemon’ cucumber. It’s like a very mild, very sweet cucumber; a taste most people appreciate.

3 lemon cumbers, two ripe yellow fruits, one over ripe orange fruit.
Be careful to harvest on time! By the time the fruit begins to turn orange, its taste and texture are declining. Photo; mschuppi, depositphotos

American Samuel Wilson’s catalog was the first to offer ‘Lemon’ cucumbers. That was in 1894. Here is part of the description: “They are considered a great dainty by those who are fond of that popular vegetable. They have all the desired qualities of a good cucumber, slightly flavored with lemon, which gives them a decided advantage over the common kind.” Soon, it was fairly widespread in both the Old and New Worlds under the cultivar name ‘Lemon’.

These days, given the great popularity of heritage vegetables, seeds of ‘Lemon’ cucumbers are not at all hard to find. Look online and you’ll be surprised at how many catalogs offer them. I grew a few plants myself this summer, for the first time in over 40 years.

Why Is the Lemon Cucumber Round?

Three lemon cucumbers, one cut open to sow the 5 locules inside.
Lemon cucumbers owe their rounded shape to their locules (seed compartments); there are 5 rather than 3. That tends to produce a rounder fruit. Photo:

Wild cucumbers have either 3 or 5 locules: compartments in which seeds are produced. Garden cucumbers have 3. As with peppers, this leads to a naturally oblong shape. ‘Lemon’ has 5 and this naturally gives it a more rounded form. Certainly, however, developers of ‘Lemon’ must have done some tweaking, selecting the roundest fruits in each generation to stabilize its now near perfect tennis ball shape.


If I had to rate the ‘Lemon’ cucumber on anything other than originality or mild flavor, I don’t think I’d give it great grades.

It’s slow to mature, not very productive and certainly not very disease resistant. However, it has been used in hybridizing to introduce reduced cucurbitacin and other traits. And if any reader has an interest in trying to develop round cucumbers, it could certainly be part of your hybridizing program.

Other than that, it’s a standard, easy-to-grow cucumber. Start it indoors in the early spring and plant it in the garden or a container in the summer. You can read more about how to grow cucumbers here: 10 Tips for Growing the Best Cucumbers.

Woman hitting lemon cucumber with tennis racket.
There are things you shouldn’t do with a lemon cucumber, like using it as a tennis ball! Photo: Luckybusiness & mschuppi, depositphotos

I would not, however, recommend trying to play tennis with the fruits, as tantalizing as their perfectly round shape might make that possibility seem!

To read more about the ‘Lemon’ cucumber, go to the site: Origin and Characterization of the ‘Lemon’ Cucumber where a full report by R.W. Robinson of the Horticulture Department at Cornell University awaits you.

Garden writer and blogger, author of 65 gardening books, lecturer and communicator, the Laidback Gardener, Larry Hodgson, passed away in October 2022. Known for his great generosity, his thoroughness and his sense of humor, he reached several generations of amateur and professional gardeners over his 40-year career. Thanks to his son, Mathieu Hodgson, and a team of contributors, will continue its mission of demystifying gardening and making it more accessible to all.

4 comments on “The Story of the Lemon Cucumber

  1. Although it is not one of my favorites, everyone else likes it, and it is happy to grow over the junipers on the edge of the driveway below. It has been one of the more reliable varieties for us. Cucumbers grow in the spring and again in the early autumn here, but generally roast through summer in between. (We can plant them twice annually, but generally do not expect them to perform all the way through the arid summer.) This one seems to last longer into summer, and has even been productive through summer. (It produced early, and as vines wore themselves out through summer, new vines emerged from the roots!)

  2. Derek Bull

    These are a must.
    Late to get going but all of a sudden they are all over the place!
    all of my buddys love them and they keep very well in the fridge for a couple of weeks and are the ideal size for a good salad.
    very much recommended!

  3. Interesting article. Cute little fruits. Have always been intrigued so might put them on the seed list this Spring. Have tried a couple of unusual Asian varieties with different coloured skins. A bit of a novelty in amongst the green ones. Tastes don’t differ that much though.

  4. MaryAnn Caton

    I have been growing lemon cucumbers for three years now. Maybe it’s because of my living in Zone 5 in Pennsylvania, but my crop is always huge and I can’t eat or give them away fast enough. Our honey bees love working the flowers and mine are exceedingly disease resistant. I’ve also seen a second variety known as an Apple Cucumber.” It is shaped something like a sheep’s nose apple. Have you tried them?

Leave a Reply

Sign up for the Laidback Gardener blog and receive articles in your inbox every morning!