Saving seed Sowing Seeds

Hybrid, Open-Pollinated or Heirloom Seeds: The Choice Is Yours!

Spring is the time to buy seeds, and if you haven’t already, it’s about time you did. When you’re out shopping, you’ll sometimes notice the words hybrid, open-pollinated or heirloom on the packaging of certain seeds. What does all this mean, and why is it important?

Hybrid Seeds

A hybrid plant is the result of crossing two different varieties or species, usually using controlled reproduction techniques. This process makes it possible to combine the desirable characteristics of each parent, but these plants do not faithfully reproduce the same characteristics as their parents, and the seeds they produce will not give the same results. Hybrid plants are sometimes sterile. The term F1 refers to the first generation of hybridization.

Stabilized hybrid seeds are seed varieties that have been selected and reproduced to fix and stabilize certain genetic characteristics. Originally, these seeds are produced as a hybrid, whose desirable characteristics may vary or be lost in subsequent generations. Breeders therefore work to stabilize these characteristics through several cycles of selection and reproduction. The resulting seeds are considered stabilized hybrids, and retain the desired genetic characteristics from one generation to the next.

It’s important to note that hybrid plants are not genetically modified organisms (GMOs). Hybrids are the result of a cross between different varieties of the same or closely related species, whereas GMOs are organisms whose genetic material has been modified by genetic engineering techniques to introduce specific characteristics. Hybrid plants can even be found in the wild.

Tokyo Market is open-pollinated. Photo: Jardins de la Gaillarde

Open-Pollinated Seeds

Open-pollinated seeds are produced naturally by sexual reproduction between plants of the same or closely related species. These seeds can be harvested from plants that have reproduced naturally, without human intervention to control pollination, or that have been hand-pollinated.

Unlike hybrid seeds, open-pollinated seeds retain the genetic characteristics of the parent plant and can be used to reproduce similar plants in subsequent generations.

Heirloom Seeds

The Italian Principe Borghese tomato is a much-loved ancestral variety. Photo: Semences Nordiques

Heirloom seeds are plant varieties that have been cultivated by farmers and gardeners for generations, even millennia. They have been developed and adapted to the specific conditions of a given place, often by indigenous or local communities. They are open-pollinated.

The Big Debate: Hybrid Versus Open Pollination

Every time I present a text that includes plants grown from hybrid seeds, I receive, shall we say, unpleasant messages. It seems that hybridization arouses the passions of certain readers! Why is this?

Despite a certain hostility towards them, hybrid seeds do have certain advantages.

Advantages of Hybrid Seeds

Tomate Celebrity
Celebrity’ tomato, an F1 hybrid variety. Photo: OSC Seeds

To begin with, hybrid seeds are reputed to be hardier, more resistant to disease and more adaptable to certain unfavorable conditions. They have been developed precisely to respond to problems of disease, pests and climatic conditions. More resistant plants are less dependent on pesticides and fertilizers.

Hybrid plants are often more uniform in size, color and taste, and their yield is also more consistent, which is an advantage for vegetable growers. What’s more, they are often produced by large companies that have the means to carry out rigorous tests to guarantee their quality and performance.

Disadvantages of Hybrid Seeds

While they may look miraculous on paper, there are not only advantages to using hybrid seeds. Firstly, the research required to develop these varieties is expensive. As a result, hybrid seeds are more expensive than open-pollinated seeds, due to the significant investment required in selection and production.

Since they are not faithful and are often sterile, they have to be reproduced from the parent plants, which means buying new seeds every year rather than saving seeds from year to year, limiting the autonomy of gardeners.

The sterility of certain hybrid plants can, on the other hand, be an advantage in the case of ornamental plants. It prevents exotic species from spreading through an ecosystem and displacing native varieties.

Hybrid are often blamed for the loss of genetic diversity, which would affect crop resilience to environmental change and disease. I believe this argument is only valid if you don’t save parent lines or if you stop using open-pollinated seeds, which isn’t necessarily the case, but it’s still a potential danger.

As far as I’m concerned, one of the major disadvantages of using hybrid seeds is that they are often produced by large multinational companies with a dubious sense of morality.

Advantages of Open-Pollinated Seeds

Meadow sage is an open-pollinated variety.Photo: Anokian

So are open-pollinated seeds better?

By using them, gardeners can harvest and save their own seeds, reducing costs and dependence on seed suppliers. These seeds also help preserve the genetic diversity of crops, enabling greater adaptability to environmental changes. Open-pollinated seeds are often adapted to specific local conditions, as they have been developed and selected locally.

But what’s most important, in my opinion, are the links forged between local seed producers and the farmers and gardeners who use them. Exchanges between these people not only deepen knowledge, but also create a community, not least through events such as seed festivals.

Genetic diversity is crucial for adaptability to climate change, disease and pest resistance, agricultural productivity, biodiversity conservation and scientific innovation. Greater genetic diversity means that there is a greater variety of traits and genetic responses available, increasing the chances that a population can survive and adapt to new challenges. This reduces the likelihood of the entire population being affected by a single disease or pest, and helps maintain crop health and productivity. Genetic diversity provides an invaluable source of genetic material for scientific research and technological advances. The loss of this diversity can lead to reduced ecological resilience and negative impacts on ecosystems and the species that depend on them, including ourselves.

Disadvantages of Open-Pollinated Seeds

It’s not all black and white! Open-pollinated seeds have a certain variability, making results less predictable and uniform than with hybrid seeds. Sometimes, harvests are lower than with hybrid plants, and they may have less resistance to disease. What’s more, they can reproduce with other plants of the same species in close proximity, diluting desirable characteristics and diminishing crop quality. Open-pollinated seeds may require more intensive crop management to prevent and control pest problems. They may also have limited adaptability to specific conditions, unlike hybrid varieties which are often developed to be resistant to specific environmental problems.

Heirloom Seeds

The Oka melon is a heirloom variety.Québec. Photo: Jardins de l’Ecoumène

Ancestral seeds have the same advantages and disadvantages as open-pollinated seeds. They are adapted to local conditions, contribute to genetic diversity and enable gardeners to save their own seeds. However, they can have variable yields and are generally less resistant to disease. That said, they are an integral part of our cultural heritage. By cultivating them, we preserve not only genetic diversity, but also cultural diversity.

The Choice Is Yours!

So, hybrid, open-pollinated or heirloom seeds: which will you choose?

Personally, I love all plants and believe that each has its place. However, I’m partial to passionate seed growers who produce open-pollinated and heirloom seeds locally, usually organically, but always with respect for the environment and our communities.

Mathieu manages the jardinierparesseux.com and laidbackgardener.blog websites. He is also a garden designer for a landscaping company in Montreal, Canada. Although he loves contributing to the blog, he prefers fishing.

4 comments on “Hybrid, Open-Pollinated or Heirloom Seeds: The Choice Is Yours!

  1. Joel LeGrand

    All open pollinated & heirloom seeds are from hybridization of select breeding & later cross breeding for hundred of years.
    Whole books have been written on the history of seed & how man made peaches & melon larger & taster.
    It is now believed that Figs are the first plant farmed.

  2. “As far as I’m concerned, one of the major disadvantages of using open-pollinated seeds is that they are often produced by large multinational companies with a dubious sense of morality”. This is in the hybrid section therefore should this not be the major disadvantage of using “hybrid seeds” and not open-pollinated seeds?

    • Bill Russell

      Mathieu, I had the same reaction when I read it. It looks to me like a mistake, as well.

      • Mathieu Hodgson

        Thanks for pointing that out! I’ve corrected the mistake.

Leave a Reply

Sign up for the Laidback Gardener blog and receive articles in your inbox every morning!