Gardening Laidback Gardener Tip of the Day Perennials Plant Hardiness

Warning: Giant Fleeceflower May Sucker

 

20161017a

Highly promoted by Dutch plant whiz Piet Oudolf, a leader in the New Perennial Movement, the giant fleeceflower (Persicaria polymorpha) first appeared in North American nurseries in the early 2000s and has quickly become one of the most popular perennials.

This giant plant (it can exceed 8 feet/2.5 m in height under some circumstances!) bearing large creamy white feathery plumes is now found in many home and public gardens. It has proven easy to grow, very hardy (zone 3), extremely weed resistant and very long-blooming (it literally blooms all summer and into fall). It truly is an extraordinary plant and is, in fact, remains my favorite perennial. You’ll find more information about it here: Growing Giant Fleeceflower.

However, while the giant fleeceflower has always been presented as a totally no-care plant, with no flaws whatsoever, it has recently begun revealing a dirty little secret. Mature plants, after staying exactly where they were planted for a decade or more, have begun to show they have a hidden suckering habit. This completely contradicts what gardeners are being told. Every nursery I’ve looked into says it stays put, that it never suckers. But it’s becoming apparent that this is not entirely true.

Mature Plants Seem to Sucker

20161017b
Mature giant fleeceflowers can begin to sucker.

I planted mine 12 years ago, just as it was coming onto the market, and thus have probably been growing longer than most other gardeners. It has truly been a star and I proudly showed it off to all visitors. At first, no one had ever seen one, so they were suitably impressed. Now I find most serious gardeners do know it, but still, it remains an impressive plant.

After 11 years of growing as a single clump, though, two summers ago mine suddenly produced three suckers. Not spindly little things, but big well-rooted clumps. And up to 3 feet (1 m) from the mother plant, at that. I’ll admit, this doesn’t even come close to the running stolons of the other fleeceflower relatives, the knotweeds (plants in the genera Persicaria, Polygonum and Fallopia), but still, it was a shock. After all, I’ll been promised it would never spread.

But it only seemed to have happened to me. No one else ever mentioned it. Until this summer. One of my blog followers reported “many” (no number was given) offshoots appearing all around his mature giant fleeceflower. He wanted to know what had happened. And so did I.

Seeking Information

20161017cI just got back from the 2016 Perennial Plant Conference  held at Swarthmore College, Swarthmore, Pennsylvania, where I presented a lecture on shade perennials. No less than three of the six speakers mentioned giant fleeceflower (P. polymorpha) in their presentation and all highly recommended it. None mentioned it suckering. I checked with all three after their talk and no, none had ever heard of giant fleeceflower spreading. Of course, the room was full of perennial experts and I quizzed quite a few of them. Likewise, no one had ever heard of that happening. One suggested I had bought the highly invasive and similar-looking Weyrich’s knotweed (P. weyrichii) by mistake, but I’ve grown that plant (and never will again: what a weed!) and mine was definitely P. polymorpha.

But then I talked to Cassian Schmidt, Director of the Hermannshoff Garden in Weinstein, Germany, also a speaker, and he confirmed to me that German gardeners, who have been growing giant fleeceflower for a longer time than North American gardeners, are becoming increasing concerned about its late-in-life weedy habit. I would have liked to have known if there was some specific combination of conditions, besides the plant reaching 10 years or so in age, that would provoke this sudden bout of suckering, but he wasn’t aware of any.

The Plant’s Real Name

Cassian Schmidt also informed me that Persicaria polymorpha is probably not the right name for this plant. It is apparently a natural hybrid, likely between P. alpina and P. weyrichii, that was found in Finland, and, according to him, its real name is P. x fennica or even Aconogonum x fennicum (depending on whether you’re a lumper or a splitter). He pointed out that flowers of giant fleeceflower are sterile, which would be very unusual in a true species, but common in an interspecies hybrid, because hybrid plants are often unable to produce viable seeds.

Please note I’m not trying to push for a name change (we’re only just beginning to know the plant under the name P. polymorpha and changes in botanical names cause so much confusion), but I figured I ought to let you know…

Forewarned is Forearmed

And there you go. You are now aware of giant fleeceflower’s dirty little secret: it sometimes does sucker, especially when it reaches a certain age. Of course, no one seems to know yet if this is a widespread problem or one that will be limited to certain environments. Still, at least you know about this flaw and, in gardening as in other fields, forewarned is forearmed!20161017a

Larry Hodgson is one of Canada’s best-known garden communicators. He has notably been editor-in-chief of HousePlant Magazine, Fleurs, Plantes et Jardins, À Fleur de Pot and Houseplant Forum magazines and is currently the garden correspondent for Le Soleil and radio garden commentator for CKIA-FM Radio. He has written for many garden publications in both the United States and Canada, including Canadian Gardening, Harrowsmith, Horticulture, Fine Gardening and Organic Gardening. He also speaks frequently to horticultural groups throughout Canada and the U.S. His book credits include The Garden Lover’s Guide to Canada, Complete Guide to Houseplants, Making the Most of Shade, Perennials for Every Purpose, Annuals for Every Purpose, and Houseplants for Dummies, as well as nearly 60 other titles in English and French. He is a past president of the Garden Writers Association (now Garden Communicators International) and the winner of the prestigious 2006 Garden Media Promoter Award offered by the Perennial Plant Association. He resides in Quebec City, Quebec, Canada.

15 comments on “Warning: Giant Fleeceflower May Sucker

  1. Elaine Gibson

    Hi,,,I live in Digby, Nova Scotia,Canada,,,where could I buy this plant,,,thank you,,

    Sent from my iPad

    >

  2. Ruth Summersides

    Hi, I live in zone 2b and my giant fleece flower flourishes. Oddly I have found 2 suckers this year. (I wasn’t aware that this was abnormal, but this is the first time.) So do I dig them up and transplant them? (i have had it for 10 years)
    I would appreciate any advice. thank you Ruth

  3. Francine Racette

    My White fleeceflower (persicaria polyphorma) is about 18 years old and started to sucker about 4 years ago. I was quite stunned. So i’ll try to control it because I adore it. Glad to learn I am not alone. Thank you foryour column.

    • Oddly, no one else has ever commented on this. And I see nothing on the internet on the subject. I was beginning to wonder if I was the only one with this “problem”. (ç

      Well, not really a problem, but certainly a “behaviour” I was always told this plant didn’t have.

  4. This is interesting! Is it possible that some will sucker and some won’t *because* it’s an interspecies hybrid? Maybe a minority of plants get suckering genes from one of the two original parents but most don’t.

    • That could well be. Certainly P. weyrichii is highly invasive. But even if it wasn’t an interspecies hybrid (remembering that “the jury is out” on that subject), within any given species, there are going to be differences. It could be perfectly normal for one clone to produce suckers while another doesn’t.

  5. Neil Eaton

    How do you get rid of it.we are digging it up but the deeper we go the bigger the root mass

    • Cutting it back repeatedly will work. Digging tends to spread it. Better yet, cover the plants with something that will cut out the light, like a piece of old carpet or a slab of wood.

  6. Sarah Schuepbach

    I have just dug up my beautiful white fleeceflower thinking I would move it to another part of the garden. Until I discovered a root system from hell. One of the roots was the diameter of a garden hose and several feet long. I doubt I got it all. Can I expect these roots to continue growing and producing plants. I have a similar problem with a dogwood tree that I dug up. Trying to kill it is driving me crazy. Advice please as how to get rid of this stuff.

    • You’ll have to wait and see. This plant being fairly new on the market, no one knows exactly how it reacts. If plants do pop up, just digging them out might be enough. A worst case scenario might involve cutting them to the ground and applying herbicide to the wounds.

  7. Comment from Calgary – planted 4 years ago, purchased from a local nursery. We were surprised that this year, it produced 5 suckers. It lives to the west of a close by Manitoba Maple. Go figure!

Leave a Reply

Sign up for the Laidback Gardener blog and receive articles in your inbox every morning!

%d bloggers like this: