Butterflies Perennials

My Favorite Butterfly Magnet

Eastern swallowtail butterfly visiting Phlox paniculata ‘Jeana’. Photo: mtcubacenter.org

I grow a lot of plants that attract butterflies, but my favorite is a garden phlox called ‘Jeana’ (Phlox paniculata ‘Jeana’). It just seems to outdo, for butterfly attractiveness, all the others; plus it is easily the longest-blooming phlox in my garden: from early August to early October (mid-July to early September in milder climates). Plus, it is disease resistant (no powdery mildew has ever been seen on this one!) and easy to grow. 

And I’m not the only one who says so. Although I bought this plant on a whim in a local garden center, simply based on its striking appearance, it turned out I was buying a star. 

As I was researching this article, I came across a report from Mt Cuba Center, a wonderful public garden in Hockessin, Delaware, that studied 94 phlox cultivars over a 3-year period and it concluded that ‘Jeanna’ was by far the best phlox at attracting butterflies. In fact, it was rated the best garden phlox overall! 

Monarch butterfly visiting ‘Jeana’ flowers. Photo: thegardendiaries.blog

Mt Cuba Center even created a Pollinator Watch Team specifically to understand why ‘Jeana’ attracts so many more butterflies than other phlox. Over two years, they counted 539 butterfly visits to ‘Jeana’ compared to 117 visits to the next-most popular cultivar, Phlox paniculata ‘Lavelle’.

Oddly, ‘Jeana’ is not highly scented (in fact, I can smell nothing), so it’s not perfume that’s attracting our winged friends. And an analysis of its nectar at Mt. Cuba showed it to be no different than that of other phlox. The Pollinator Watch Team concluded that it was probably the density of the flowers that made it so attractive to butterflies. There are many more flowers in a cluster than in typical garden phlox, up to 100, so butterflies can visit a lot more flowers in less time.

I think, too, it would be interesting to test how quickly it renews its nectar after a butterfly visit drains the flower. My personal theory is that it probably gushes nectar like a fountain, explaining why butterflies come back again and again.

And while butterflies adore it, in my garden, it attracts its fair share of hummingbirds, too. Often you see both on the same plant at the same time.

What Does It Look Like?

Phlox paniculata ‘Jeana’ is a big one, towering above other garden phlox. Photo: stonehousenursery.com

Phlox paniculata ‘Jeana’ is immediately distinguishable from any other phlox because of the size of its panicles (flower clusters)—6 inches/15 cm across!—, the huge number flowers per panicle … and their small size. The petals are half the size of other garden phloxes and the tube behind the flower is shorter too. It’s the mass of flowers makes for its impressive appearance! Individually, the small flowers are out and out wimpy!

As for color, what can I say: it is simply pink, phlox pink, the color of wild P. paniculata flowers, with a darker eye. After all, ‘Jeana’ is not a hybrid, but was chosen from the wild. It was discovered by Jeana Prewitt from a large P. paniculata colony on the Harpeth River in Nashville, Tennessee. 

And ‘Jeana’ is a big one. Although the plant label on my plant gave its height as 2 to 4 feet (60-120 cm), Mt. Cuba lists it as 5 feet (150 cm). In my garden, it’s that tall too: a head above any other phlox. It is a sturdy, upright, conical perennial forming a dense clump of narrow, pointed deep green leaves to 4? (10 cm) long with that characteristic huge cluster of tiny pink flowers on top.

That said, I recently saw a severely drought-stressed ‘Jeana’ that really was only 2 feet (60 cm) high. Although it was immediately recognizable due to its enormous head of small flowers (‘Jeana’ looks like no other phlox!), there was a label near the plant confirming its name. So, expect some variability in ‘Jeana’s height.

Growing ‘Jeana’

Phlox paniculata ‘Jeana’: the flowers may be small, but there are lots of them! Photo: mtcubacenter.org

All you need are typical garden conditions to grow ‘Jeana’ to perfection: full sun (partial shade is acceptable) and good, well-drained garden soil. It will even grow in clay soils, although a lighter soil is better. Once established, it is reluctantly drought tolerant, but will be much happier if you water it during times of drought. In spite of its height, I’ve seen no signs of flopping. And it’s said to be hardy from zones 4 to 8. I suspect it would be hardy in zone 3 too.

Besides being extremely resistant to powdery mildew, it will tolerate being grown under black walnuts (Juglans nigra), resists deer and rabbits and is not normally prone to insect damage. I’m not sure about Japanese beetle damage, though (there are none where I live, so I can’t check): if any reader has information on that subject, I’d appreciate knowing and will update the article as needed.

If you like it, ‘Jeana’ is easily multiplied by cuttings or division … and makes a great cut flower.

Hey, ‘Jeana’ is just about the perfect garden phlox … except for the absence of perfume, which is a bit of a downer. Well, I suppose you can’t have everything!

I heartily recommend ‘Jeana’, available in better garden centers across North America and soon, one would hope, elsewhere in the world. Try it and see!

Garden writer and blogger, author of 65 gardening books, lecturer and communicator, the Laidback Gardener, Larry Hodgson, passed away in October 2022. Known for his great generosity, his thoroughness and his sense of humor, he reached several generations of amateur and professional gardeners over his 40-year career. Thanks to his son, Mathieu Hodgson, and a team of contributors, laidbackgardener.blog will continue its mission of demystifying gardening and making it more accessible to all.

3 comments on “My Favorite Butterfly Magnet

  1. Christine Lemieux

    I have never had mildew on Phlox paniculata David, but it is not a butterfly magnet. If I can find Jeana here I will remove some milkweed in my pollinator garden as I have so much of it, to make room. Thanks!

  2. We just discovered phlox last year, when it just showed up on its own. It looks like ‘David’, but lacks fragrance. It spread significantly for this year. If I were to select a variety, it would look just like this. The white is so perfect. It does not seem to attract butterflies, but there are not many in that particular area to attract.

  3. My mother in law has so much phlox in her garden. Personally I think it’s an ugly flower. But I do like how many butterflies it attracts…. It’s a bit of a love-hate relationship for me lol.

Leave a Reply

Sign up for the Laidback Gardener blog and receive articles in your inbox every morning!

%d bloggers like this: